Stop aliasing String.t and integer

I’m learning Elixir and, a little unwillingly, learning about it’s system of type specifications. I will concede that being able to specify the types of return values is helpful but I am not sure about the rest. Nevertheless I am told the Dialyzer system (that analyses type information and looks for errors) can be very helpful so for now I am playing along.

While reading the documentation something caught my eye:

Defining custom types can help communicate the intention of your code and increase its readability.

defmodule Person do
   @typedoc """
   A 4 digit year, e.g. 1984
   """
   @type year :: integer

   @spec current_age(year) :: integer
   def current_age(year_of_birth), do: # implementation
end

I found myself puzzled by this statement. The argument in question year_of_birth is already clearly indicating it’s a year. And the type cannot enforce the rule “A 4 digit year, e.g. 1984”.

So what is the type spec adding? It seems to me that what it’s adding is a step of cognitive overhead in understanding that what is being passed is an integer.

I’ve seen other examples of creating types for username and password that alias the String.t type and again I find this unconvincing since the function being spec’d almost certainly calls it’s arguments username and password so what is being added?

Where a type adds useful information I buy it. A struct for example is already a kind of alias since it defines compound structure. But for primitive types like String.t and integer it seems like adding aliases is hiding information not adding to it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.